Quote:
Do a search and you should find a lot of material. The AVMA has come out against early spay and neutering and now recommends owners wait a year. Remove the testicles and you affect the endocrine system of the dog and this is never a good thing.
Quote:
Controversial. Reward based dog trainers believe he forces the dog into a state of learned helplessness - what he calls "calm submissive." I agree to a point but also think this is necessary in many cases to break unwanted behavior and rebuild desired behavior. As long as the dogs aren't being smacked around (necessary in some cases) I don't see it as a problem. If the bottom line is, "Jesus Christ, lady, take your dog for a walk, stop treated it like a ******* child, and cut out the bullshit" I think it's a pretty good thing. Mind you, it's a TV show and things are not quite as they appear.
Barking is a *****, particularly in herding dogs. There's an old adage that says, "teach your dog to bark on command then never give him the command" but I'm not sure that will help you. It takes a lot of effort to get a dog to stop barking at outside noise. Sometimes though it can be as simple as letting him have his head then praise and distract. "That'll do, pig."
Castration will "fix" none of these problems. It can alter future behavior in a puppy since you're cutting off a serious amount of hormone, but that's not to say that different unwanted behaviors won't crop up. There is no cure for submissive urination. You can mitigate it by changing your behavior toward the dog if that effort is worth it.
I ran into a college friend whose new wife has effectively cut off his balls. He asks for permission to piss so maybe it does have an effect.
Exercise solves a lot of issues in dogs and people.
lefty
Do you have any reading material for opponents to castration? I've never seen any but I don't frequently read about dogs.
Do a search and you should find a lot of material. The AVMA has come out against early spay and neutering and now recommends owners wait a year. Remove the testicles and you affect the endocrine system of the dog and this is never a good thing.
Quote:
What's the general consensus about Cesar and his training methods? I watched a few of his videos (not the TV show) and it helped a lot with some of an extremely dominant Corgi's behavior but not all. My girlfriend did agility classes and most of the trainers use strictly pro-rewarding methods rather than establishing pack leader stuff. To clarify, reward methods for obedience as well, not just for agility.
My Corgi continues to bark a lot at outside noises. Door, garage opening, etc. I understand they're almost hardwired to be good guard dogs but it gets annoying.
Controversial. Reward based dog trainers believe he forces the dog into a state of learned helplessness - what he calls "calm submissive." I agree to a point but also think this is necessary in many cases to break unwanted behavior and rebuild desired behavior. As long as the dogs aren't being smacked around (necessary in some cases) I don't see it as a problem. If the bottom line is, "Jesus Christ, lady, take your dog for a walk, stop treated it like a ******* child, and cut out the bullshit" I think it's a pretty good thing. Mind you, it's a TV show and things are not quite as they appear.
Barking is a *****, particularly in herding dogs. There's an old adage that says, "teach your dog to bark on command then never give him the command" but I'm not sure that will help you. It takes a lot of effort to get a dog to stop barking at outside noise. Sometimes though it can be as simple as letting him have his head then praise and distract. "That'll do, pig."
I was under the impression that neutering the dog would help with the excitement . . . am I wrong?
My friend always thought it was cruel as well and it would completely change the dog post operation.
^and the barking as well. i thought neutering would fix all these behaviors..
Castration will "fix" none of these problems. It can alter future behavior in a puppy since you're cutting off a serious amount of hormone, but that's not to say that different unwanted behaviors won't crop up. There is no cure for submissive urination. You can mitigate it by changing your behavior toward the dog if that effort is worth it.
Well, I can't under stand why cutting your balls off would keep you from taking a piss when excited. Maybe a lobotomy would help... but seriously three are no magic fixes. Just be aware that a dog with balls can knock up other dogs.
Exercise is the closest thing to a fix all, IMHO.
I ran into a college friend whose new wife has effectively cut off his balls. He asks for permission to piss so maybe it does have an effect.
Exercise solves a lot of issues in dogs and people.
lefty