Great info, look forward to seeing the finished product. So the original Bond's go-to shoes might be along the lines of Cleverley's George model. Do you think this would still be the choice of a Bond who was born in 1990?I've actually researched the issue of these loafers a lot as Bond is one of my earliest and biggest style influences. While I agree with you about Fleming's Bond not being a dandy, I think he would go bespoke. The books are very clear that he strongly subscribes to the old English reverse snobbery of buying only a few things of the highest quality and then wearing them until they are threads or fall apart. So I think Bond would be a bespoke guy, although like Fleming definitely off-Row and looking for a good value.
The novels also indicate that Bond's loafers have bespoke details like throwing knives concealed in the heel. Old Bond scholars like Kingsley Amis were of the opinion that Bond's intended shoemaker was Nicholas Tuczek given the reference to his signature "square toe" by Fleming in the letter and the fact that Tuczek's shop was next door neighbours with a bladesmith.
Fleming also tended to give Bond a lot of his own style quirks like the preference for short sleeve shirts (Fleming worked as a journalist and hated getting newspaper ink on his shirt cuffs. Also lived half the year in Jamaica.). Based on the types of apron toe penny loafers Fleming wore, my best guess for what Bond's loafers looked like is this vintage Lobb pair (except in black):
Fleming can be seen in photos wearing loafers and other slip-ons with a similar soft square toe shape.
Now if you are connecting the dots between all of this research and my recent commission of Tuczek-inspired soft square toed penny loafers, you would be very correct. Also, until they are ready, I am wearing my RTW John Lobb Lopezes. 😉