STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.
Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.
Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!
Styleforum is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.
To try and answer your question in a different way: My 42 in Jamieson's is pretty much spot on equivalent to a Medium "classic" fit from J.Press (and relatively comparable to a 40 in O'Connells). In my case, I like my shetlands to look like JFK wore his, where they fold and rumple around the arms and fold over the bottom hem, so a 42="Medium".Bought a couple of Jamieson's, including the Duke reverse because, just, obvsly. Just double checking that your size listing is their normal sizing convention where a 40" on their attached label has a L on the sweaters tag, and a 42" has an XL on the tag, and when you say "size up" you are referring to the letter on the tag and not from my normal Jamieson's size?
To try and answer your question in a different way: My 42 in Jamieson's is pretty much spot on equivalent to a Medium "classic" fit from J.Press (and relatively comparable to a 40 in O'Connells). In my case, I like my shetlands to look like JFK wore his, where they fold and rumple around the arms and fold over the bottom hem, so a 42="Medium".
No sizing override, we go off the tagged size they arrive with. The size 42 is tagged as an L though...Great feedback, though I have several Jamieson's, so I'm familiar with how I like them to fit standardly. For me the 42 (labeled on the attached tag) does fit how you say, but if you look at the neck tag, it probably says that sweater is an XL. (Though I personally find the classic medium at J Press has sleeves a bit too short for me, and the large unfortunately not closed enough at the waist).
All I'm checking is that NMWA didn't "override" the standard labeling, which some resellers do. Like End Clothing sells Jamieson's as 42(L), which doesn't actually "exist." What you'll get is a 42 that fits like a L (or really a medium as you say) but says XL on the tag. Makes it sometimes a gamble ordering from some retailers when you don't really know which size you might get.
I saw someone on reddit post the same sweater. Such a nice color for cool tone outfits this time of year.Wore my verdegris jamieson’s yesterday size 44. We have different colors now but you will still look cool I promise (some support from camoshita coat and inglese popover)
View attachment 2091497
Wore my verdegris jamieson’s yesterday size 44. We have different colors now but you will still look cool I promise (some support from camoshita coat and inglese popover)
View attachment 2091497
I saw someone on reddit post the same sweater. Such a nice color for cool tone outfits this time of year.