Red Wing Boots - Your Opinion

[EPrest90]

Does anyone know if redwing still offers the free replacement laces somewhere on their website?

Not online. Either call and they'll mail them to you, or go to your local store.

 

[Schnurretiger]

I'm considering getting some RWs as my next boot, but I'm not sure which is best for my needs. Thinking about either the Blacksmith or the Beckman. What I'm not sure about is the sole: I'll be wearing the boots mostly around town, but also quite frequently on gravel, sandy paths, grass and muddy roads. Would this favor the Beckman boot?

 

[Mr Engineer]

I'm considering getting some RWs as my next boot, but I'm not sure which is best for my needs. Thinking about either the Blacksmith or the Beckman. What I'm not sure about is the sole: I'll be wearing the boots mostly around town, but also quite frequently on gravel, sandy paths, grass and muddy roads. Would this favor the Beckman boot?

I personally think the Beckman has better color options

 

[spedrunr]

I think the major difference is the sole material. If you are in a wet environment, the Blacksmith has a full rubber/cork sole. The Beckman has that leather section between the heel and forefoot that would rot over time (unless you can use some sort of water sealant)

I live in the southwest where it's very dry so I don't worry about my Beckmans too much.

 

[Schnurretiger]



I personally think the Beckman has better color options

I didn't ask about color options.

I think the major difference is the sole material.  If you are in a wet environment, the Blacksmith has a full rubber/cork sole.  The Beckman has that leather section between the heel and forefoot that would rot over time (unless you can use some sort of water sealant)

I live in the southwest where it's very dry so I don't worry about my Beckmans too much.

I've got some resoled harness boots with a leather section in the middle and they have been fine for the past 10 years, even in the wettest and muddiest of weather conditions. No rot or anything, if taken care of properly. Any input on traction of the Blacksmith on gravel or wet rocks?

 

[Betelgeuse]

Got the Beckman's yesterday, I fall in love with them.

Got them at a really nice price since the store isn't going to carry the brand anymore, got them for $243 usd.

 

[Neognosis]

I, too, have had a pair of motorcycle boots with a half sole and exposed leather under the instep for around 7 years. Resoled twice, all kinds of wear in all kinds of weather, and no problems with the exposed leather.

Here's my Beckmans. Daily wear since August. Just gave them a quick shine.

 

[emarcus62047]

I just purchased a new pair of Red Wing Heritage 8146 6" work boot at my local Red Wing Store.

I'm going through the dreaded "Break In" period, my ankles are killing me but getting better each day. I knew up front that my feet and ankles would be sore but would eventually adapt and the boots should serve me well.

I work on concrete floors at Lowes and this boot was rated number 1 for support when standing and working on concrete floors.

The only thing that concerns me is there is no Red Wing logo stamped into the outside of each boot as I've seen in most pictures of these boots.

Is this normal or is it possible that have I purchased a "knockoff"?

Thanks in advance for any replies

 

[NCowardParody]

It's normal!

 

[emarcus62047]

Thanks very much,

That's what I wanted to hear.

Just finished a 3 mile walk with my dog wearing them and they get better each time.

Have a great day.

 

[Betelgeuse]

Can I use a little amount of wax on the Beckman boots? Not a mirror shine, just a small layer of wax to keep them protected?

 

[Sunstealer73]



Can I use a little amount of wax on the Beckman boots? Not a mirror shine, just a small layer of wax to keep them protected?

I use Allen Edmonds shoe creme on my Chestnut Beckman's. I hit them with conditioner, let them dry, wipe on the creme, let it dry, buff with an old t-shirt, and then buff with a brush.

 

[ElBron21]

I didn't ask about color options.
I've got some resoled harness boots with a leather section in the middle and they have been fine for the past 10 years, even in the wettest and muddiest of weather conditions. No rot or anything, if taken care of properly. Any input on traction of the Blacksmith on gravel or wet rocks?

I doubt that guy cares if you asked about color options or not, so dont be rude.
I have Beckman's and 2 IR's with the nitrile cork that the Blacksmiths have.
The Beckman's commando sole would work better maybe in 'gravel or wet rocks,' the difference aint much bc the lug of the sole isn't substantial enough.
If youre walkin in that often, the only heritage line boots I would suggest are the 877s which I own and can vouch for in such conditions. Or go buy hiking boots.

 

[ElBron21]

Got the Beckman's yesterday, I fall in love with them.

Got them at a really nice price since the store isn't going to carry the brand anymore, got them for $243 usd.

Great find my friend! Enjoy them, dont baby them

 

[ElBron21]

Can I use a little amount of wax on the Beckman boots? Not a mirror shine, just a small layer of wax to keep them protected?

You can use wax, but there is better stuff out there. Shinola has great stuff made for high quality leather, Sno-Seal is absolutely amazing for water-proofing, and Bickmore products (particularly bick 4) are great. I personally use all 3 on mine. Id shy away from a lot of Red Wing's boot oil stuff because if you look at some products it is says on the bottle "not recommended for suede or fine leathers." Which is dumb bc that's what I own.