Kapital - hippies, Japanese farmers and post-apocalypse survivors

[hoodog]

I am sure you have olive outerwear as well. If you don’t or feel the overlap with the EG Barbour is too much, get the olive.

Is the EG Barbour lined or only a shell? Either way, the long Ring is very different.

The Barbour has more functionality as a proper piece of outerwear whereas the long Ring is a fun piece, but not very practical, if that is important to you. The cotton version of the long Ring offers little warmth in cold weather. You would need to layer a thick knit or a puffer underneath for the colder temperatures. Conversely, in warmer weather up to the 70s F, I have not been tempted to wear a long (non-rain) coat. So for me, the long Ring on its own is only relevant for a few months of the year.

Ymmv.

The EG is lined with cotton. So not very warm either.

I know all about the ring coat and warmth/isolation since I have the regular one in both cotton and wool. The wool version is actually less warm than the cotton one. But I also have the RC liner which I use during winter which makes the piece surprisingly warm. These past few years my cotton RC with liner has been my go to coat during winter.

 

[bry2000]

Got it. Sounds as if you should go for the black then.

 

[hoodog]

Got it. Sounds as if you should go for the black then.

How do you figure?

 

[masshi]

get both

 

[bry2000]

How do you figure?

If you are going to winterize the long ring with the liner, I like the idea of a quirky, forbidding black coat in the city in the Winter.

 

[Timbaland]

The EG is lined with cotton. So not very warm either.

I know all about the ring coat and warmth/isolation since I have the regular one in both cotton and wool. The wool version is actually less warm than the cotton one. But I also have the RC liner which I use during winter which makes the piece surprisingly warm. These past few years my cotton RC with liner has been my go to coat during winter.

That's surprising about the cotton being warmer. Is the RC liner warm on it's own (I assumed it was less warm than the cotton RC) or is it that just put together it is warm? Can't tell if it's more like a shell that can be worn on warm days (~75F) or fairly substantial.

 

[peachfuzzmcgee]

Honestly once I grab my ring coat it's probably going to go on sale. I love the look but its just not very practical, too cold when it's cold, too warm when it's warm.

The black one is a statement, I think the olive is the only way to go. Long black coats are such a vibe that doesn't fit with most things for me.

 

[hoodog]

That's surprising about the cotton being warmer. Is the RC liner warm on it's own (I assumed it was less warm than the cotton RC) or is it that just put together it is warm? Can't tell if it's more like a shell that can be worn on warm days (~75F) or fairly substantial.

Well the wool version (the "vintage melton wool") has a pretty open weave which does a bad job at stopping the wind. It just blows right through. I live in a fairly windy place, so its not a very good combo for me. The cotton weave is much denser and so it at least keeps the wind out. So for my conditions, the cotton RC offers better isolation/warmth.

The RC liner is warm on its own. I would never wear it at temps higher than say 10°C. However, I find the liner pretty hard to wear on its own, because of its fit and how it closes/buttons. So I usually just wear it as a liner inside the RC.

 

[d4nimal]

Agree on the cotton somehow being warmer than the wool for the reasons you listed. I’ve had the same experience. Very surprising the first time you’re out in the cold expecting it to do something.

 

[KaleidoscopicK]

My experience with the navy melton wool rings true (har har) to what @d4nimal and @hoodog have written. If you layer appropriately - and you'll have the room to do that - then it'll usually be fine. But if you go out with it in cold, windy weather with only a thin shirt and aren't just going from the car to the house door...

 

[hoodog]

Well I bought both the black and the olive. Just couldn't make the choice. I'll flip the one I like the least when I have them in hand. 💪

 

[shishy]

I have the wool ring coat in navy blue (pendleton one). It's true that the weave is loose and not so good in wind but if you put one of those ultralight down jackets from uniqlo or something similar under it's pretty much perfect.

 

[peachfuzzmcgee]

Honestly the Melton wool one sounds better for socal winters than my current denim one. Maybe I'll try to switch out someday. I'm finally going to pick up all my winter clothes from Chicago and I'm gonna need to sell quite a few

 

[ghdvfddzgzdzg]

with the wool ring coat, once you put on a shirt, a big sweater, and then the ring coat, which is its own scarf, it's pretty good in cold weather. that many layers stops the wind. i'd prefer it to the cotton in weathery circumstances, since the wool one, when rainy, will still be somewhat functionally warm if you have layers under it. but if i was wearing just a tee or something under it, yeah i guess i'd want the cotton because indeed the wool is a looser weave. iirc i wore my cotton one once last winter, and maybe not at all the year before, but my wool one several times each winter.

regarding the eg/barbour vs the cotton ring coat, i find the eg barbour much warmer once you get layered up. that liner, plus the waxed fabric, matters. it's been my go-to bad weather winter coat since 2018, just with a good sweater and a tee under that. i've been so impressed with that thing.

 

[hoodog]

Selling a Jubbahn Shirt in size 4 that I got for a friend but didn't work out. Listed on Grilled but will sell to SF doods for JP retail plus fees. DM me if you're interested!