Cashmere scarves?

indianshaft · Jan 20, 2011

How do you know if a scarf is good quality or not?

I recently purchased a 100% cashmere scarf but it feels thin, compared to others that I have looked at.

Are there some general characteristics in determining if a scarf is good or not? Also, is there a way to tell if it is 2ply (I think that is the term) or not?

Thanks for the help.

dragon8 · Jan 20, 2011

I can feel the difference. Good cashmere is unbelievably soft.

westinghouse · Jan 21, 2011

Check out Ralph Lauren Purple Label cashmere scarves. They run about $600 and are super thick.

GBear · Jan 21, 2011

Or look into the Alex Beggs of Scotland scarves.

glum · Jan 21, 2011

i recently bought a ralph lauren scarf (not purple label) that is cashmere and is so thick. cost about 100$.

Leaves · Jan 21, 2011

There are different grades of cashmere qualities, so just because it's cashmere does not automatically mean it's good stuff. A high quality wool scarf could be much nicer to the touch than a low grade cashmere scarf.

Also, just because a cashmere scarf is thick does not mean it's of good quality. The Rubinacci cashmere scarves are very thin but unbelievably soft (I can pull it through my wedding ring and it's about 200 cm x 100 cm large).

aj_del · Jan 21, 2011

Originally Posted by Leaves

There are different grades of cashmere qualities, so just because it's cashmere does not automatically mean it's good stuff. A high quality wool scarf could be much nicer to the touch than a low grade cashmere scarf.

Also, just because a cashmere scarf is thick does not mean it's of good quality. The Rubinacci cashmere scarves are very thin but unbelievably soft (I can pull it through my wedding ring and it's about 200 cm x 100 cm large).

Dealers of shahtoosh in Delhi like to boast that only a shahtoosh shawl can pass through a ring

Leaves · Jan 21, 2011

Originally Posted by aj_del

Dealers of shahtoosh in Delhi like to boast that only a shahtoosh shawl can pass through a ring

Go to a Rubinacci store and try it for yourself.

upr_crust · Jan 21, 2011

Originally Posted by aj_del

Dealers of shahtoosh in Delhi like to boast that only a shahtoosh shawl can pass through a ring

Pklease also note that shahtoosh is illegal to import into the US, as the animal from which it is made is endangered, and the current methof of production of shahtoosh requires that the animal be killed.

Originally Posted by Leaves

Go to a Rubinacci store and try it for yourself.

If in doubt, bring a married friend with big fingers.

.

Mr. Lee · Jan 21, 2011

Rub it and see if your fingers feel greasy--bad sign. Johntsons (Johnsons?) of Scotland (I belive) makes nice ones. I have one of my Dad's that's at least 25 years old and no sign of wear. In contrast, I have a couple of J Crew cashmere sweaters that are two years old and shot.

aj_del · Jan 21, 2011

Originally Posted by Leaves

Go to a Rubinacci store and try it for yourself.

I was not challenging your statement, merely stating that dealers in shahtoosh mislead buyers here.

Shahtoosh is also illegal in India and some years there was a scheme to get your existing shahtoosh stuff registered with the government. If you are caught wearing shahtoosh today and you cant produce the registration to prove that you had it before it was banned, you are liable to be prosecuted. Needless to say the shawl will be confiscated.

DorianGreen · 2025-01-20T04:04:02-0800

Joshua Ellis in cashmere.

A lovely blue with olive overchecking.

Cashmere scarves?

Senior Member

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Member

Affiliate Vendor

Distinguished Member

Affiliate Vendor

Distinguished Member

Senior Member

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Classic Menswear Featured products

Similar threads

Featured Sponsor

Plain hem

Cuffed (1.5 inches or less)

Cuffed (more than 1.5 inches)

No preference, as long as the proportions work

Forum Sponsors

Forum statistics

FOLLOW STYLEFORUM ON: