Which pair of suede loafers is better for casual summer use?

[Ddubs]

I am looking get one of the attached loafers from Meermin for casual summer use. I'm not sure which one fits the bill better in terms of the shade of brown and last. I already have a very dark brown pair so want something lighter. Which do you prefer or would say is more versatile?

 

[NORE]

I like both, but what i would do is get a tassel loafer in one shade, and a penny in the other. ~$400 for 2 pairs of shoes to alternate in S/S makes plenty of sense to me.

I got the darker tassel and plan on getting the lighter penny very soon if I replace these.