robinsongreen68
Distinguished Member
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2006
- Messages
- 2,434
- Reaction score
- 2,737
As an exercise, I just made a sketch of a lapelless coat. It is the type of sketch that I'd have made if someone told me "Design a lapelless coat". I had not seen any pictures AFAIK, of Peir Wu's coat, before hand. I am also not a designer, so though I've been exposed to fashion for a long time, I am not subject to the same aesthetic conditioning that designers that have gone to a design school have.
I then googled "Peir Wu lapelless coat", and they looked, perhaps unsurprisingly, fairly similar. The only images that I had in my head when making a sketch was a vague recollection of a Margiela lapelless coat, a picture I'd seen years ago in an LN-CC lookbook, and a Marni coat my wife has worn for years. I simply took the lapels off of that and tried to create a tulip shape when I took the lapels off.
I think that there are only so many ways to design a lapelless coat, maybe.
i certainly don't disagree with this type of argument, or what the woman in DWW's video seems to be saying from a quick scan. I come from the art world, day one lesson one at any decent art school would be that there's no such thing as originality, steal anything and everything etc. despite this i still find it distasteful to see big conglomerates doing straight rip-offs of small independent designers, who are almost invariably struggling just to pay the rent. in peir's case, as others have pointed out, there were other pieces that they also blatantly copied. i'm sentimentally attached to the idea that there is a difference between picking up that lapel-less coats are cool and setting out to make one vs simply scanning a collection and saying 'right we're going to copy that and that and that', although the distinction is probably meaningless in reality.
the whole idea of the free flow of information/ideas is obviously great, but it starts to feel like the flow is overwhelmingly in one direction ( of course this is just life under hyper-capitalism or wherever we are now, but equally i dunno if it helps that we all become apologists for that process, even just by default).
Last edited: