The coat and fit looks great on you, I often look for longer coats, can be very hard to find.Thanks for all the replies guys, really helpful to hear everyone’s opinion.
Here’s another pic with a chunky knit as requested (I was wearing a pretty thin polo in the original).
View attachment 2065563
Still on the fence a bit as I kind of agree with every opinion so far, but maybe it’s just a matter of getting used to the voluminous nature of it. The sleeves definitely should get shortened a bit though. I think that’ll clean it up.
Don’t shorten the total length, it seems very risky, just shorten the arms.