- Joined
- Oct 12, 2006
- Messages
- 15,054
- Reaction score
- 2,487
I voted for mildly consumptive, who managed to have a lot of things going on while still keeping a harmonious look. He got extra points for including shoes and socks, and while the tie was solid, it made good use of texture.
Brownshoe was hurt by bad photography - I couldn't really see the details of his entry.
Edmorel's entry had many of the virtues of mildly consumptive, but was just a little too gimmicky in the use of brown and blue. It is a combination I like and use, but I decided to give the nod to the more classic entry.
Baron could have gotten first place too, but mc's bonus points for socks and shoes tipped the scale.
bigbris, master shake were too loud for my taste. zipj3's entry, while loud and colorful, was killed by the suit. The closed up 3 roll 2 is just too stiff for such exuberant colors. Paired with a nice and easy two button or DB summer suit and I would have given this more consideration (as a bonus, if that is an RLPL square, I have the same one) (oops . . I just noticed that zipj3 didn't make the official entry cut, but I will leave the comments in).
Aharris's entry is a clear winner for real life business wear. Perhaps too boardroom for this contest, but perfect in every way.
iamatt: There is no use talking to this guy. His best bet is to turn off the lights before choosing a square.
Brownshoe was hurt by bad photography - I couldn't really see the details of his entry.
Edmorel's entry had many of the virtues of mildly consumptive, but was just a little too gimmicky in the use of brown and blue. It is a combination I like and use, but I decided to give the nod to the more classic entry.
Baron could have gotten first place too, but mc's bonus points for socks and shoes tipped the scale.
bigbris, master shake were too loud for my taste. zipj3's entry, while loud and colorful, was killed by the suit. The closed up 3 roll 2 is just too stiff for such exuberant colors. Paired with a nice and easy two button or DB summer suit and I would have given this more consideration (as a bonus, if that is an RLPL square, I have the same one) (oops . . I just noticed that zipj3 didn't make the official entry cut, but I will leave the comments in).
Aharris's entry is a clear winner for real life business wear. Perhaps too boardroom for this contest, but perfect in every way.
iamatt: There is no use talking to this guy. His best bet is to turn off the lights before choosing a square.