Men's Vogue to close?

gorgekko · Oct 30, 2008

MV turned into a horrible magazine and it will not be missed.

LabelKing · Oct 30, 2008

Men's Vogue was slightly marsupialed as was Classic Style--that cellphone holster ad scarred me for life.

whnay. · Oct 30, 2008

Originally Posted by LabelKing

Men's Vogue was slightly marsupialed as was Classic Style--that cellphone holster ad scarred me for life.
You mean the pics of overweight middle aged men in balloon pants and wide pinstripes didn't do the trick?

LabelKing · Oct 30, 2008

Originally Posted by whnay.

You mean the pics of overweight middle aged men in balloon pants and wide pinstripes didn't do the trick?

Apologies to the modern-day goon-apes out there, but no.

earthdragon · Oct 30, 2008

For those in LA.
Asahiya on Sawtelle and Kinokinuya in Little Tokyo have a good selection of Japanese Mags, (Mens Ex, Leon etc).

jpeirpont · Oct 30, 2008

Originally Posted by whnay.

You mean the pics of overweight middle aged men in balloon pants and wide pinstripes didn't do the trick?

On purpose?

robin · Oct 30, 2008

Originally Posted by spectre

Where do you get this? Is it monthly?
Kinokuniya in Seattle. Think it comes monthly, though they just started it last month. It's focus is much more on runway fashion, with great layouts and photography, and not so much of Men's Ex type coverage.

jamesbond · Oct 30, 2008

I dont feel Mens Vogue is as bad as people are saying. I mean its not great but miles better then GQ which has been reduced to a bunch of ads these days. I was just about to fill out my renewal when i saw this post. Just saved me $30.00 bucks, thanks!

LabelKing · Oct 30, 2008

Of men's magazines, I far prefer the European ones: Vogue L'Uomo, Arena Homme Plus, Les Officiels Hommes, etc.

The Americans also have VMan, but that is far too homoerotic for any sensible style advice.

Christofuh · Oct 30, 2008

Originally Posted by jamesbond

Just saved me $30.00 bucks, thanks!

That shallow shyte cost you $30 ???
I thought it was under $10 for the whole year

rach2jlc · Oct 30, 2008

As many others, I eagerly anticipated the first few editions but quickly got bored and saw no reason to keep looking.

Can't say this one will be missed... it was a good idea that could/should have been taken farther than the diluted, boring, light direction it went.

acidboy · Oct 30, 2008

For the price via subscription, I'm not complaining 'bout MV. It is what it is, I say- a great read in the crapper. My wife will be happy when she finds out though... less junk in the room.

gorgekko · Oct 30, 2008

Originally Posted by LabelKing

Of men's magazines, I far prefer the European ones: Vogue L'Uomo, Arena Homme Plus, Les Officiels Hommes, etc.

The Americans also have VMan, but that is far too homoerotic for any sensible style advice.

So the European magazines are only moderately homoerotic?

It seems every time I buy something like Vogue L'Uomo I end up seeing more of a man than I ever wished.

HORNS · Oct 31, 2008

The last issue was so thin I could have read it from cover to cover while in line at the grocery store. I was pissed at myself for buying it after looking at it when I got home (and I do mean look - there was nothing worth reading) that I felt that this was the harbinger of things to come. I guess my feelings were right. As for you San Francisco guys looking for the Japanese magazine discussed, I would think it would be available at the Japanese bookstore in Peace Plaza in Japantown.

Sator · Oct 31, 2008

Originally Posted by JLibourel

A lot of truth in that. From the outset I noticed that there was something schizoid about the magazine. On the one hand, they wished to reach out to men who liked to dress with classic elegance in timeless style. On the other hand, a lot of their core market were retro costumers. I think making the first issue a "hat" issue with the back pages filled with pictures of Fedora Lounge get togethers may have poisoned the wells as far as getting advertising from mainstream advertisers like Ralph Lauren, Hickey-Freeman, HSM, A-E, Alden, Brooks Brothers, Canali, Corneliani, etc., who might naturally advertise in a true "classic style" magazine but wouldn't be uninterested in as tiny a market as the costume boys. The fact that most of the advertising they did get was costume-oriented would undoubtedly force them to continue to cater to this market as well as reinforce the impression that it was primarily a costume magazine. The whole thing was a great pity. Had it succeeded it could have occupied a good niche. There was much that I liked about the magazine.

I must confess with some guilt that I never really enjoyed the magazine myself. Somehow, even when lively writers were engaged, their style got cramped, their voice never really emerged. Will's ASW is always lively, but his writing on CS seemed to have been written by someone else. I wonder if the editors were at fault.

You might have thought that with my interest in dress history the magazine would be perfect for me. However, I hardly learned a thing from all the pages. As you say, the FL is more about costume as an end in itself. I freely admit that most historic costume looks terrible. History is the waste bin of affected fashions - or worse, a vast waste bin of plain indifferent dullness for the average man who cared little about dress. Harsh though that is, it seemed that CS drew its very life and breath from that bin

Most men of the past were far from looking like walking fashion plates. For example, here is a fashion plate showing a striking coat with a high one button closure and V shaped cutaway front:

In reality, this is how this style worked out for the average man:

Hardly inspiring stuff. The boots are even more atrocious. History is fascinating, but the Brummells and D'Orsays of the world were less than one in a million even in their age. Aping history as an end in itself results in mere stage costuming.

Men's Vogue to close?

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Prof. Fabulous

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Classic Menswear Featured products

Similar threads

Featured Sponsor

Plain hem

Cuffed (1.5 inches or less)

Cuffed (more than 1.5 inches)

No preference, as long as the proportions work

Forum Sponsors

Forum statistics

FOLLOW STYLEFORUM ON: