Thank you for your thoughts. I, and am sure others, appreciate your experience. I would really like to hear your review about the passus shoes your ordered once they arrive. I am familiar with the noble shoe. I purchased a pair of CS hand gradeshoes and was impressed with the customer service and the value of the shoe.If I may add a few thoughts to your purchasing decision. Although after I provide you my thought, I am interested in what kind of shoe are you looking for.
I do not own the shoes yet, so what I am about to say is purely conjecture.
Based on the materials used, the kind of construction employed, where the leather is and can be sourced from, and (not to be forgotten) the customer service. Passus should be the best value under $1000. Of course, we are talking in the middle tier range so anything $500+ but under $1000.
You have great options in which to choose, but also have an eclectic selection. G&G makes a beautiful shoe, but, IMO, I much rather have the other three options (StC, Passus, and PS). I base that predominantly on the construction method. The other point is any of the three companies provide you MTO possibilities. Yes G&G does, but you'd pay a substantial upcharge for an already expensive shoe (most expensive on your list).
So that leaves you the next three. This selection comes down to taste. PS has a really Italian aesthetic. Passus an Eastern European one. Stc is sort of a mix of the two.
If it's an economic issue, choice is easy. Passus! Same construction as the other two. Possibly same leather. Many MTO options. Somewhat limited in terms of lasts, but that's why I prefaced these thoughts with the question of the sort of shoe you are searching for.
If you are looking for a shoe with just a touch more refinement, StC. They also have many lasts in which to choose, loafers, boots, etc. Pricer than the other two and customer service is..........
PS is your Italian choice, and by that I mean the vibe. It really is just a very different shoe, compared to the other two. This is your "swag" shoe.
One point that bears mentioning is customer service. Often you hear days or weeks go by without a response. Sometimes people do not receive a response period. Often, I have heard of companies not taking responsibility for their errors. Blaming the customer at that. More often than not, you are not kept in the loop as to how your shoe are progressing, where they are in terms of reaching their destination (the client). Hell, sometimes the shoes just look crappy, and they are like well you deal with it.
With Passus, Rezso specifically, you get the GOLD standard. The man is a pleasure to do business with. Have an idea.. Write him. Question about a shoe or your shoe.. Write him. Question about the company.. Write him. This kind of service is a rarity these days, so when a company exhibits the kind of customer service they do...You must applaud them for it.
I mentioned I did not have their shoes yet, but I ordered from Passus. In fact, I ordered based on the word of two men involved in other shoe companies. If their competitors (albiet not in the same price range) praise them (specifically mentioned Rezso), that's more than enough for me.
Now if you do decide to go the Paolo Scafora route, you should reach out to @Noblekostas at the Noble Shoe. He is the Gold standard amongst solo acts.