Patrick R
Distinguished Member
- Joined
- Sep 29, 2011
- Messages
- 4,656
- Reaction score
- 11,887
My take: Kurt was a more unique, gifted songwriter who came from a different but accessible angle. Dave is better at writing mass-appealing rock with great hooks. Also, Dave comes at it a bit different in his guitar chords and phrasing but that's on the more technical side. Kurt didn't do anything that required obvious technique and dexterity, but he was very in tune with minor chord progressions and melody. Dave is, as you said, a musicians musician. Would he been as successful? Well, I can't see something like Pretender or Times Like These being easily ignored. So he would have found some success for sure. But This is a Call and I'll Stick Around needed something like Nirvana proceeding it to turn people onto atypical rock like those songs. In short, Foo Fighters are Nirvana if Nirvana intentionally set out to write radio-friendly, modern rock with a unique twist.
Recommended watch, specifically around 5:32 and on, and 12:40 and on:
I have worked really hard to not get worked up by this thread, but this is the worst of all takes and makes me want to never come back to this website.